Researchers test 'grit' as weed-control option

"True Grit" is taking on new meaning for agricultural researchers, who are finding high-speed particles from ground corncobs can help control weed infestations in row crops. In collaboration with South Dakota State University researchers, U.S. Department of Agriculture agronomist Frank Forcella has devised a tractor-mounted system that uses compressed air to shred small annual weeds with the organic grit.

Ongoing field trials may determine the system's potential to help organic growers tackle within-row infestations of weeds that have sprouted around the bases of corn, soybean and other row crops.

Dubbed "Propelled Abrasive Grit Management" (PAGMan), the system disperses 0.5-millimeter-sized grit particles in a cone-shaped pattern at the rate of about 300 pounds per acre, using 100 pounds per square inch of compressed air.

An SDSU engineering team built the machine under a grant Forcella was awarded from the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture.

"For the first few weeks of the growing season, weeds are relatively small, and that's when we target them with the grit," said Forcella, who works at the Agricultural Research Service North Central Soil Conservation Research Laboratory in Morris, Minn.

The crop plants escape harm because they are taller than the weeds, and their growing points are protected beneath the soil or by thick plant parts, he said.

Current organic weed-control methods include flaming (scorching), soil tillage and hand-pulling, among others.

Weeds remain a chief agronomic concern requiring new approaches, said Forcella.

This summer marks a second round of field tests of PAGMan on multiple rows of silage corn grown on 10-acre plots of certified organic land in Minnesota.

"Last year, in corn with its full complement of weeds, we were able to get season-long weed-control levels of 80 to 90 percent using two treatments of the abrasive grit—one at the first-leaf stage and the second at the three- or five-leaf stage of corn growth," Forcella said, noting corn yields compared favorably to those in hand-weeded control plots.

Initially, PAGMan consisted of a hand-held nozzle and compression hose hitched to a grit-filled tank on the back of an all-terrain vehicle. The tractor-mounted version uses an air compressor to pump the grit through eight custom-made nozzles capable of covering a four-row area.

"We use corncob grit for our tests, but other agricultural residues could also be used," Forcella said.

Organic growers suggested using corn gluten meal as a way to fertilize crops and blast weeds simultaneously.

"We tried corn gluten meal and found it just as effective," he said. "The amounts necessary for controlling weeds were similar to those used to supply nitrogen to organic crops."

Forcella has published results from earlier, small-plot studies in Weed Technology and other peer-reviewed journals. Results from the 2013 field trials were presented this year at the Weed Science Society of America's annual meeting.

"Whacking Weeds Organically" was published in the July 2014 issue of Agricultural Research magazine, online at www.ars.usda.gov/is/AR/archive/jul14/.